Rethinking Arts Philanthropy A New Report From The Cultural Policy Unit

Who Will Pay for Britain's Cultural Future? Rethinking Arts Philanthropy A new report from the Cultural Policy Unit

 

Here is a brief interpretation of the latest report From The Cultural Policy Unit. Read the full report Here

Britain’s cultural institutions are facing an uncomfortable question. Who will pay for their future? For years, museums, galleries and arts organisations have been caught between diminishing public support, rising costs and an increasingly competitive search for private money. Philanthropy has become more important. But the system supporting it has barely kept pace with the demands being placed upon it.

A new report from the Cultural Policy Unit, published in November 2026, makes an ambitious case for reform. It wants Britain to become a more attractive destination for cultural giving. It also wants the government to stop treating philanthropy as an occasional supplement to public funding and start recognising it as part of the country’s cultural infrastructure.

The proposals range from tax incentives for artists donating their own work to a new King’s Philanthropy Medal for Culture. There are plans for a national match-funding scheme, a network connecting donors with cultural organisations, and a major initiative called Arts for Every Child. It is an ambitious agenda. It also raises a difficult question about the future relationship between private wealth and public culture. The money is there. The challenge is getting it into the right places.

The growing dependence on private wealth

There is ample evidence that substantial philanthropy can transform cultural institutions. In 2025, the National Gallery announced Project Domani, a major transformation programme for which £375 million had already been secured. This included two gifts of £150 million, from the Crankstart Foundation, established by Sir Michael Moritz and Harriet Heyman, and the Julia Rausing Trust. They were the largest individual donations ever reported by a UK museum. The Science Museum also received its largest international gift, an eight-figure donation from India’s Serum Institute, to support the redevelopment of a gallery.

Elsewhere, Igor Tulchinsky’s reported $6.8 million sponsorship of the British Museum’s Bayeux Tapestry exhibition demonstrated the scale of international corporate support available to major institutions. These gifts are impressive. They are also revealing. Britain’s largest cultural organisations can attract extraordinary sums when a donor’s interests align with an institution’s ambitions.

But what happens to organisations without access to a wealthy international network?

The report identifies a growing concentration of philanthropic funding. London accounts for around a third of UK philanthropic giving. Smaller regional organisations often struggle to establish relationships with donors, even when their work has clear local value. There is another concern. As public funding becomes more constrained, cultural institutions risk becoming increasingly dependent on a relatively small group of wealthy individuals.

That dependence can influence priorities, even without direct interference. Donors have their own interests, preferences and ideas about what deserves support. Institutions must retain the freedom to make decisions based on their artistic and public responsibilities. The report is clear that increasing the amount of private money is not enough. Britain needs more donors, not simply bigger donations from the same people.

An artist’s gift should count.

One of the report’s most interesting proposals concerns the tax treatment of artists who donate their own work. Under the current system, cash donations can attract Gift Aid. For every £1 donated by an eligible UK taxpayer, a charity can generally reclaim an additional 25p from HMRC. In 2024 to 2025, Gift Aid payments to charities reached £1.71 billion. But an artist who gives a valuable painting or sculpture directly to a museum does not receive equivalent tax recognition based on its market value.

An artist might donate a work worth £10,000 to a gallery. The gallery could subsequently sell it to raise money for its charitable activities. Yet the artist cannot claim tax relief on the work’s market value under the ordinary rules for such donations. Would a donor handing over £10,000 in cash receive different treatment? The report considers this an anomaly. It argues that the tax system recognises financial generosity but fails to acknowledge the contribution of artistic value.

This is not an insignificant issue for contemporary art. Institutions such as Tate are increasingly interested in donations of works by living artists as part of their fundraising and endowment strategies. Smaller galleries could benefit too. The South London Gallery, which provides free access to its community, is cited in the report as an organisation that could gain from a more generous framework.

The proposed solution is to allow artists to receive tax relief based on an independent valuation of their donated work. The report suggests using the valuation expertise already available through the Acceptance in Lieu process. It would need safeguards against inflated valuations. But the principle is straightforward. An artwork given to a public institution should be recognised as a contribution with measurable value. There is something rather perverse about a system that encourages someone to donate money but offers no comparable recognition when an artist gives a work of considerable worth.

Keeping Britain’s cultural inheritance in public hands

The report also wants to strengthen two existing schemes, Acceptance in Lieu and the Cultural Gifts Scheme. Both allow culturally important objects to enter public collections through tax arrangements rather than direct government purchases. Acceptance in Lieu enables taxpayers to settle inheritance tax liabilities by transferring significant cultural objects to the nation. The Cultural Gifts Scheme allows individuals and companies to donate important works during their lifetime in return for reductions in tax liabilities.

Together, the schemes have brought objects worth approximately £60 million into public collections in recent reporting periods. They are valuable mechanisms. But they are not working at their full potential. The combined annual limit has remained at £40 million in tax settled since 2014 and has periodically been exhausted. The report recommends increasing this to approximately £63 million in 2025 prices.

It also wants the administration simplified.

Donors currently face restrictions on how tax credits are allocated over time. If their financial circumstances change, the original arrangements can become inconvenient or even wasteful. The government has announced some reforms for April 2027. The report argues that further flexibility is necessary. The objective is to prevent important works from leaving Britain or disappearing into private ownership simply because the available tax arrangements are too restrictive.

There are wider questions about international giving too.

Britain attracts major cultural donors from the United States, Asia, the Middle East and Europe. Yet the mechanisms for making tax-efficient donations to British institutions can be complicated. The report proposes a national framework for international cultural philanthropy, including donor-advised funds, partnerships with established overseas giving organisations, and a central advisory service. It wants Britain to compete more seriously for international philanthropic capital. That ambition is understandable. But it also highlights how dependent the cultural sector is becoming on the cross-border movement of private wealth.

A medal for giving

Money is one incentive. Recognition is another. The report proposes establishing a King’s Philanthropy Medal for Culture, a national honour specifically recognising exceptional contributions to the arts. Britain already recognises philanthropists through the honours system. But there is no dedicated national award for cultural giving.

Other countries have taken a more visible approach.

France has used its national honours to recognise major cultural patrons, including François Pinault and Bernard Arnault. The United States has the National Medal of Arts and the Presidential Medal of Freedom. South Korea also has a national Order of Cultural Merit that can recognise foreign contributors.

Britain has a precedent of its own. As Prince of Wales, King Charles established a Medal for Arts Philanthropy, presented to donors including Sir Terence Conran and Terry Bramall.

The report wants to revive that idea with greater national standing.

It argues that cultural philanthropy should be celebrated as a contribution to public life, rather than treated as a private transaction between a donor and an institution.

There is, however, an important qualification. The medal should not simply reward the largest cheque.

The report proposes recognising sustained commitment, innovation, public benefit and the willingness to support projects that might otherwise struggle to attract funding.

Smaller organisations and regional initiatives should be represented.

That distinction matters. If national recognition becomes another means of celebrating the wealthiest benefactors, it risks reinforcing the very concentration of influence the report wants to address.

Matching money with ambition

Perhaps the most consequential recommendation is the creation of a national cultural match and seed funding programme. The principle is that government money should be used to attract additional private investment.

There is already evidence that this can work.

The Big Give’s Arts for Impact campaign in March 2024 raised £2.85 million through 12,386 online donations. Approximately £1.3 million came from philanthropic matching pledges. Of the participating charities, 66 per cent had annual budgets below £1 million. Some 76 per cent of the money went to projects outside London. A survey found that 84 per cent of participating donors were more likely to give when their donation was matched.

These figures suggest that match funding can reach beyond the usual circle of major patrons. It can encourage smaller donations, bring new people into philanthropy and give regional organisations a better chance of securing support.

The report also points to the longstanding partnership between the Department for Culture, Media and Sport and the Wolfson Foundation. Since 2002, the programme has awarded more than £50 million to improve museums, including regional institutions.

The proposed national scheme would build on these examples.

But the report distinguishes between matching and seed funding. A developed project may be ready to attract a substantial donation. An early-stage idea is different. It may need money for planning, staffing, research and testing before it can persuade anyone to invest.

The proposed seed fund would support this earlier work.

Government and private donors would be involved from the beginning, helping projects establish their purpose and consider how successful initiatives might eventually expand.

There would be evaluation and clear criteria. Public money should not automatically guarantee further funding if a pilot fails to deliver. This is a sensible distinction. Cultural organisations often have good ideas but lack the resources to develop them into fundable projects. The report wants government to take some of that early risk.

The regions cannot remain an afterthought.

The geographical imbalance in British philanthropy is one of the report’s strongest concerns. London continues to attract a disproportionate share of cultural giving. Regional institutions often have to compete for attention with internationally recognised museums and galleries that have much greater fundraising capacity.

The report argues that the answer lies in place-based philanthropy.

Rather than trying to persuade donors to support an abstract national cause, organisations should build relationships around places that have personal meaning to them. Stoke-on-Trent’s Made in Stoke and Blackpool’s Pride of Place are examples. Both bring together local authorities and private donors to support community projects. The report also refers to the Figurative Philanthropy for Arts and Culture initiative, which has developed 20 place-based partnerships.

Local pride can be a powerful motivator. A donor may be more interested in supporting a museum, festival or youth arts project in the town where they grew up than contributing to another large national institution.

But these relationships require investment in their own right.

Smaller charities need fundraising staff, administrative support and the ability to present their work convincingly. They cannot be expected to compete for wealthy donors without the necessary infrastructure. The report therefore proposes mapping cultural provision and philanthropic funding at postcode level.

This would give government and funders a clearer picture of where cultural opportunities exist, where they are missing and which communities are being overlooked. It is an important shift from simply following wealth to identifying need.

A new generation of cultural donors

The report also looks towards the next generation of philanthropists. It estimates that between £5 trillion and £7 trillion could pass from older generations to younger people by 2050.

That transfer of wealth represents an enormous potential source of future charitable giving.

But younger donors are unlikely to respond to traditional fundraising in the same way as previous generations. The report argues that cultural philanthropy needs to feel more relevant, social and entrepreneurial. Music festivals, fashion collaborations, technology, digital campaigns and creative education could all provide routes into giving. There is a suggestion that young people should be given responsibility for distributing philanthropic money themselves. One proposal is a philanthropic capital fund for a cohort of young people, potentially funded in part by Dormant Assets. They would make investment decisions with support and mentoring from established philanthropists.

It would be a practical education in how giving works.

The report also wants philanthropic planning to become a more familiar part of financial advice, particularly as wealth transfers between generations. The larger point is that philanthropy should not be something people encounter only when they inherit money or become wealthy. It should be part of a wider culture of participation.

Arts for Every Child

The most ambitious idea in the report is Arts for Every Child. It proposes a broad national commitment to creative education, supported collectively by government, philanthropists, schools and cultural organisations.

The report argues that Britain needs a clearer route from a child’s first encounter with the arts to more advanced participation and professional training. Sport offers an obvious comparison. Children can move from school activities to local clubs, specialist coaching and professional pathways.

Creative education is less consistently organised.

Schools cannot provide everything. Museums, galleries, libraries, theatres, music organisations and local arts groups all have a role to play. The report seeks a national picture of existing provision and the gaps that need to be filled. It also identifies the National Centre for Arts Education as a potential coordinating partner. The intention is to make creative opportunity less dependent on where a child happens to grow up or attend school.

This is perhaps the proposal with the clearest public purpose. It moves the discussion away from the fortunes of individual institutions and towards the cultural opportunities available to the next generation. It also gives philanthropists something tangible to support.

Who sets the priorities?

The report concludes with a proposal for a senior national philanthropy lead, connected to No. 10, who would bring government departments, donors and cultural organisations together. A Cultural Philanthropy Taskforce would support the work by involving the Treasury, the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, Arts Council England, and representatives of the cultural and philanthropic sectors. The aim is to create a coherent national strategy rather than a collection of disconnected initiatives.

There is a difficult balance to strike.

Private donors can bring ambition, expertise and money. They can also take risks that public bodies may find harder to justify. But cultural institutions must remain independent. Public priorities cannot be determined by the personal interests of individual benefactors. The report acknowledges this, insisting that public bodies should retain responsibility for setting overall priorities and that donor involvement must be transparent.

It is an essential safeguard.

The comparison with France, Italy, Germany and the United States is useful. Italy’s Art Bonus offers a 65 per cent tax credit for eligible cultural donations. France provides generous tax incentives for corporate giving. Germany embeds charitable donations within a broader civic framework.

But Britain cannot simply import another country’s system.

It needs a model that reflects its own institutions, tax arrangements and cultural landscape. The report’s central argument is that philanthropy should become a more accessible and visible part of national cultural life. Whether the government is prepared to give that ambition the necessary financial and political support remains to be seen. Britain’s arts sector does not need another statement of good intentions. It needs practical changes to ensure money reaches the organisations and communities that need it.

The largest donations will continue to attract headlines. The real test will be whether a small regional gallery can persuade an artist to donate a work, whether a local museum can find a new benefactor, and whether a child growing up far from London can access the same creative opportunities as one growing up in the capital. Those are less glamorous measures of success. They may also be the most important.

The question is no longer whether private philanthropy has a role in Britain’s cultural future. It already does. The question is whether the country can build a system in which that support serves the public, rather than simply the institutions and individuals best placed to attract it.

Read Full Report Here

Visit